Whole new ‘town’ with marina planned just over a mile from Fishlake
Thousands of homes are set to be built in high-risk flood zones across England, an Unearthed investigation has found, including in the areas hit by the latest floods in Yorkshire and Lincolnshire.
Using the Environment Agency (EA) flood risk map, Unearthed looked at house building plans in the 10 English councils with the highest percentage of high flood risk. It identified plans to build 9,688 homes in some of the most flood-prone areas in England.
The investigation reveals:
- Across Lincolnshire, which currently has five flood warnings in place, 5,227 homes are planned in high-risk flood zones.
- The developments include Boston United Football Club’s new 5,000 seater stadium.
- In Sheffield and Doncaster hundreds of new-builds are planned in high-risk zones. In addition, 5,123 homes are planned for medium-risk areas, including a “new town” just over one mile from Fishlake, which has seen heavy flooding this week.
Separate figures obtained from the EA show that in 2017-18 in almost half the cases where the agency objected to a planning application from a local authority, the environmental watchdog did not know whether its advice was followed.
Commenting on the findings, Greenpeace UK chief scientist Dr Doug Parr said:
“Flooding has been flashing on the radar as one of the major impacts of the climate emergency in the UK for years, yet our planning system keeps failing to properly recognise it. Planning for thousands of new homes to be built in areas at high risk of flooding is literally planning for disaster. And disaster is only going to become more and more likely as the climate crisis loads the dice in favour of more and more floods.
“One of the problems is that by cutting the budgets of both local authorities and the Environment Agency, the government has effectively tilted the playing field in favour of developers. We have a housing policy that tends to put housebuilders’ profits before people’s chances of not seeing their homes underwater.
“It’s high time both local and central government started treating the climate emergency as if it was real – because it is. This also means rethinking where and how we build homes, giving more powers to environmental watchdogs to keep developers in check, and investing more in preventing floods from happening.”
Unearthed found that a major development project in a medium-risk flood zone is planned just over a mile from Fishlake, near Doncaster, one of the worst-hit areas in the country. The DN7 Unity scheme, which has been called a “new town” by Doncaster Mayor Ros Jones, promises to deliver 3,100 homes, a new school, a transport hub, and a marina.
Meanwhile, figures obtained by Unearthed from the Environment Agency through a Freedom of Information request suggest the body may not be able to protect new developments from flooding.
When a developer wants to build on a floodplain, the local authority will send the application to the EA for it to examine. The EA will then send the council a note, which could refuse the application or accept it, but with conditions. The council has no obligation to go along with this recommendation and doesn’t even have to tell the EA what it decided
According to the figures obtained by Unearthed, the EA has objected to 14,532 planning applications – equivalent to 246,944 homes – over the last five years. The agency claims that 96% of decisions taken by local authorities were in line with its advice. But this number only takes into account cases where local authorities informed the agency if they were going to follow the EA’s advice. The figure does not include the sizeable number of cases where local authorities don’t respond.
The figures show that local authorities only informed the EA of their decisions in 10,050 cases. This means there are another 4,482, or 31% of all those from 2013 to 2018, where the agency has no idea whether its advice was followed. For the most recent period, 2017/18, local authorities did not notify the EA of the outcome of a full 1,185 objections, or 43% of the total for the year.